Dutton Ranch ended with violence and tragedy, just like the show that spun it. Actually, comparisons between Yellowstone and Season 1 of this new Beth and Rip show may be too apt, but we'll get there. A trailer for Episode 9 showed gunmen approaching the Dutton Ranch and Rip throwing bodies into a mineshaft he dubbed the new train station earlier in the season. It didn't hint at the most shocking death, who was responsible and what Carter and Oreana's future looks like.