Holding centres, set up under an executive order issued by the Bengal government, and ‘pushbacks’ are part of an opaque regime that runs parallel to courts and accountability Ipsita Chakravarty Published 11.08.26, 09:17 AM The government guest house in Tentulia serving as a ‘holding centre’ Sourced by the Telegraph The ‘holding centre’ in Tentulia is a repurposed government rest house called ‘Pather Sathi’. Local police and the Rapid Action Force patrol the precincts.
Wrote 'Dapaan: Tales From Kashmir's Conflict', teaches writing @jsjc_jgu.
Formerly @scroll_in, @IndianExpress, @ttindia, @timesofindia
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Ipsita Chakravarty
Investigation uncovers coercive tactics Hindutva groups use to battle 'love jihad'
“Look, there is some truth in these cases of love jihad around here… There is someone or some organisation behind it. For instance, in the beginning, boys would roam around on motorcycles in front of schools or colleges or plus-two schools wearing a kalawa (a red thread around the wrist), using names like Sonu, Monu, pretending to be Hindus.
The conjuring: A spectral chronicler of Kashmir’s buried histories - Telegraph India
It may never be known whether the ghosts of Kashmir were psy-ops or whether they rose out of repressed traumas. But they did come to embody secret histories of a conflict under censorship Ipsita Chakravarty Published 01.09.25, 07:52 AM A Kashmiri muslim woman during a protest of the death of teenager Zahid Farooq on February 05, 2010 on the outskirts of Srinagar. Getty Images Last month, the Jammu and Kashmir home department decreed that 25 books would be forfeited from the public.
Kashmir’s Secret Languages of Dissent
A ladi shah is a satirist wearing an oversized tweed robe and a conical white cap. He is carrying an instrument in the shape of a large-sized pincer whose metal discs strike against each other to produce notes. And then he begins in a droning voice, one quatrain after another. The historical role of the ladi shah is that of a satirist. He is a perceptive observer, distilling the events around him, and rendering them into the musical performance.
Myths, hearsay, and historical memory coexist in the ways Kashmiris remember decades-long conflicts
At the mention of the daen, the 12-year-old boy reappears briefly in the 40-year-old man’s face. Yes, he knows of the daen. He has seen it. The memory is filed away as a scene from a movie. It is night, sometime in 1993. For weeks, ZM and his family have been sleeping in one room on the ground floor. Everyone sleeps early. They live in Dalgate, a neighbourhood in Srinagar where the Dal lake trails off into a channel that meets the Jhelum. It takes its name from the sluice gates that guard the Dal.
Kashmir’s Sombre Vote for Survival
Electoral politics has come full circle in Jammu and Kashmir. In the state assembly election held in 2014, the National Conference-Congress coalition had lost power. But after a decade of upheaval, the alliance will form a government again. The National Conference swept the Kashmir Valley and the Congress won all but one of its seats from there. Yet, both parties have a blemished record in the region.
Why the election noise in Kashmir is a symptom of democratic deep freeze
On the face of it, Kashmir is buzzing with electoral activity as it goes into assembly polls in three phases, beginning from Wednesday. Political constituencies that last took part in elections in 1987 are now back in the fray.
Cat calling: What should the lions and lionesses of a secular state be named?
In 1996, two men climbed into a wooded enclosure at the Alipore Zoo in Kolkata to garland a tiger named Shiva. They were said to be devotees of the goddess Durga. They were also drunk. Shiva promptly killed one of them. For several years after that, crowds would flock to the enclosure to catch a glimpse of the tiger, now stretched out on a sun-warmed rock, now just out of sight behind a copse of trees, quite unaware of the frisson of notoriety that his name had acquired.
In Manipur's Horrifying Video, a Reflection of India's Indifference
Support 'The India Forum': Help us grow. Our apologies for intruding. Please spare a couple of minutes. We are 4 now and we need your support to grow into a publication you will continue to want to read. 'The India Forum' is an experiment in reader-supported publication. It is free to read; it carries no ads and it is free of commercial backing. To make this work though and to continue to bring you informed analysis and thoughtful comment on a range of contemporary issues, we need your help.
Images of Manipur: Why the viral video needs more than a humanitarian response
It took an image. Two women, stripped naked, being led into a field that promised violence. The video went viral this week, over two months after it was filmed on May 4 in Manipur’s Kangpokpi district. It stirred a largely indifferent national public into outrage, which finally elicited a response from Delhi. After 77 days of pointed silence on the turmoil that has riven the state, Prime Minister Narendra Modi declared that “humanity has died in Manipur”.
On Rohingya refugees, AAP competes with the BJP in communal rhetoric
The fate of Rohingya refugees in India will now be decided by the competitive bigotry of the Bharatiya Janata Party and the Aam Aadmi Party. On Thursday, Union Housing Minister Hardeep Singh Puri announced Rohingya refugees would be shifted to housing for economically weaker sections in Delhi, be provided basic amenities and police protection. India had always “welcomed those who sought refuge”, Puri said.
Why are the lions of the national emblem in the new Parliament building so angry?
The national emblem on the new Parliament building, unveiled by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on on Monday, is big. Four bronze lions glower from a pedestal, standing 6.5 metres high. The lions and pedestal together weigh 9,500 kilogrammes. That is no surprise. By now it is known that the current dispensation’s aesthetic is best described as big, preferably biggest. It has under its belt the world’s tallest statue and the world’s largest infrastructure project.
Jignesh Mevani arrest shows Modi’s critics don’t have the same freedom of speech as his supporters
On Nathuram Godse, the Bharatiya Janata Party has usually maintained a happy ambiguity. Terror-accused BJP member of Parliament Pragya Thakur famously called Gandhi’s killer a patriot”. Other assorted BJP leaders, including Lok Sabha legislator Sakshi Maharaj, have also shared glowing praise of Godse. If the party high command did not quite approve, there were no political or legal costs to leaders who made such remarks, either. The adulation of Godse has become mainstream over the last few years.
How a bulldozer tore down the Supreme Court orders in Delhi’s Jahangirpuri
An hour after India’s Supreme Court ordered municipal authorities to stop demolitions in Delhi, a bulldozer came crashing down on the entrance gate of a mosque in Jahangirpuri. Muslim residents who live in housing enclaves behind the mosque stood watching through tall iron gates that were locked that morning. “But there is a court order,” one of them shouted in disbelief.
Here are five things ‘The Kashmir Files’ gets wrong about Kashmir
The Kashmir Files, directed by Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri, is not just another film. It claims to be hidden history and patriotic duty rolled into one. State governments have announced tax breaks to encourage Indians to watch the film. Government employees can get leave if they produce tickets for the film.
‘It’s like taking off clothes in public’: What Indian women say about Karnataka's hijab ban
The teacher strides up to the school gate, holding a clutch of bags. She first takes off her hijab, or headscarf. Then, heckled by others, she puts down the bags, unbuttons her burkha, lifts the garment over her head – in full public view. Watching the scene captured on camera outside a school in Karnataka’s Mandya district on Monday, Shantamma Narayana, a 43-year-old cook in Bengaluru, shook her head side to side. “This is wrong,” she said.
How the Budget fails to tackle pandemic distress and three other weekend reads
Rich man’s budget Budget 2022 ignores the acute economic distress caused by two years of the Covid-19 pandemic, writes economist Ashwini Deshpande in the Indian Express. Poverty, unemployment, welfare, food security are words that do not seem to figure in the government’s imagination. India’s battered economy needs a “broad based recovery”, not a K-shaped one that widens existing inequalities, Deshpande writes.
Pegasus scandal: Three questions the Modi government must answer about the New York Times article
A recent New York Times investigation seems to confirm something that has been widely speculated all along: Pegasus spyware entered India through a deal between governments. The newspaper alleges that the weapons-grade surveillance package was part of a $2 billion-dollar deal signed in 2017 during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Israel.
How the ‘angry Hindu’ became the new normal and three other weekend reads
A bitter harvest It has come to this – the most shocking element of the “Bulli Bai” crime was that its perpetrators were arrested, writes Satish Deshpande in the Indian Express. After all, in a political and information ecosystem where the “angry Hindu” has been legitimised, mock online auctions of Muslim women are surely not a crime? This is the culmination of a century-old project of Hindutva, founded on a hatred of Muslims, Desai points out.
Watching murder mysteries based on Agatha Christie novels
As travel bans slammed down all over the world this year, my family and I escaped to 1930s England. Every evening, prodded by my bloodthirsty grandmother, we’d gather in the living room to watch murder mysteries based on the novels of Agatha Christie. These were not the new Agatha Christie movies with star casts and clever subtexts. These were episodes made for television, mostly filmed in the 1990s and with rather poor production quality. When I was a child, they were precious contraband.
Nagaland killings: AFSPA has no place in a democratic country. It must go
The killing of civilians by military personnel in Nagaland’s Mon district has focused attention, once again, on the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act. A wide range of constituencies – the chief ministers of Nagaland and Meghalaya, political parties, Naga armed groups, civil society organisations and tribal bodies – have renewed an old demand for the repeal of the law.
An existential question for Indian politics and three other weekend reads
A new Opposition? This week, Trinamool Congress leader and West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee asked an existential question for Indian politics: “What is UPA?” The United Progressive Alliance, led by the Congress, has weathered several storms since it was formed in 2004. It had two terms in power at the Centre but is considerably battered by seven years in opposition, steered inadequately by a waning Congress. Can it still be the fulcrum of the opposition to the Bharatiya Janata Party?
Tripura Police thinks reporting on communal violence is a crime. It is not.
Its recent statements and actions suggest the Tripura Police does not understand the work of journalists. On Monday, it arrested two reporters from HW News, Samriddhi Sakunia and Swarnaa Jha, who were covering anti-Muslim violence in the state. They are accused of being part of a criminal conspiracy to spread communal disharmony and malign the government. The police claim they also fabricated and concealed records on the anti-Muslim violence as part of this conspiracy.
Shillong’s Dalit Sikhs were vital to its growth - but are being written out of its story
Punjabi Line is a densely packed strip of land on the edge of Bara Bazaar, the commercial hub of Shillong. On October 30, the Meghalaya government took possession of this land and handed it over to the urban affairs department. Several ideas have been floated about what to do with the 2.5 acres – maybe build a flyover or a parking complex, the deputy chief minister mentioned “beautification”. The verdict was that the strip of prime real estate could not be occupied by squalid homes.
Going by Home Minister Amit Shah’s logic, to strengthen democracy, Kashmir must lose it first
It was perhaps a fitting coda to Home Minister Amit Shah’s visit to Jammu and Kashmir. On October 25, the police booked students and staff at two medical colleges in Srinagar for celebrating Pakistan’s victory over India in the recent T-20 World Cup match. They face charges under the Unlawful (Activities) Prevention Act, an anti-terror law, for allegedly “crying and dancing” after Pakistan won the match.
As the prelude to Lakhimpur Kheri shows, the BJP now speaks the explicit language of violence
There was a prelude to the violence that broke out on October 3 in Uttar Pradesh’s Lakhimpur Kheri, when a convoy allegedly led by a Union minister’s son mowed down protesting farmers. Days earlier, the Union minister himself had descended on the locality to threaten and silence farmers at a public meeting.
An Indian photographer’s hateful wrath against a wounded man is not an isolated crime - it has govt's backing
In a video from Sipajhar in Assam, India that appeared on social media on Thursday, a photographer pounces on a man lying motionless on the ground, a circle of blood spreading on his chest. The photographer is accompanied by a group of policemen. He is Bijay Baniya, employed by the Darrang district administration, brought to the spot to take pictures of an eviction drive in Sipajhar. The man lying on the ground is 33-year-old Moinul Haque.
The photographer’s hateful wrath in Assam is not an isolated crime – it has government sanction
In a video from Sipajhar in Assam that appeared on social media on Thursday, a photographer pounces on a man lying motionless on the ground, a circle of blood spreading on his chest. The photographer is accompanied by a group of policemen. He is Bijay Baniya, employed by the Darrang district administration, brought to the spot to take pictures of an eviction drive in Sipajhar. The man lying on the ground is 33-year-old Moinul Haque.
Geelani, the pro-Pakistan Kashmiri leader, had not always despaired of democratic processes in India
In a widely circulated video from 2018, Syed Ali Shah Geelani is seen banging on a door, asking to be let out. “Open the door,” he says. “The funeral of your democracy is on its way.” When the 92-year-old Kashmiri separatist leader died on September 1, 2021, he had been under almost continuous house arrest for 13 years.
Why does Nepal suddenly find itself without a parliament?
Nepal has quietly plunged into a constitutional crisis. After months of tension within the ruling Nepal Communist Party, Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli on Sunday recommended that the country’s lower house of parliament be dissolved. Nepal President Bidya Devi Bhandari duly followed through. Oli’s defence: “The elected government was pushed to a corner and picketed against” by rival factions of his own party, so what could he do but dissolve parliament?
In Assam’s Bodoland, a new peace accord propelled a new party to power
After 17 years, Hagrama Mohilary will no longer be chief of the Bodoland Territorial Council. The autonomous council was created in 2003 after a peace accord between the government and a section of the Bodo groups fighting for a separate state. Mohilary, then the leader of the armed group, the Bodo Liberation Tigers, was the face of the accord.
At ceremony for new Parliament building, Modi spoke of democracy - to cover up the absence of it
Democracy was the burden of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s song as he laid the foundation stone for the new Parliament building on December 10. He invoked Guru Nanak to emphasise the importance of dialogue, perhaps as a nod to the Sikh farmers protesting at the edges of the capital. He referred to instances from 10th and 12th century India to make a case for a native tradition of democracy, apparently older than the version adapted from the West.
Anti-CAA protests vs farmers’ stir: BJP’s differing reactions betray its view of India’s Muslims
On December 11, 2019, Parliament passed amendments to the Citizenship Act that sparked an unprecedented nationwide protest movement against the legislation and other government policies that discriminate against Muslims and violate Constitutional norms. One year later, after riots in Delhi and the Covid-19 pandemic put a halt to public sit-ins, Scroll.in considers the impact of this remarkable moment in Indian history.
Why the BJP has turned a municipal election in Hyderabad into a communal battleground
In Hyderabad, a municipal election has suddenly become about polarising identities. The Bharatiya Janata Party flew in its top campaigners to namecheck all the preoccupations of the Hindu Right: Pakistan, Kashmir, surgical strikes, the Mughals, biryani, Ayodhya, Rohingya refugees. Union Home Minister Amit Shah vowed to erase the city’s “Nizami culture” and turn it into a “Mini Bharat”.
The Chinese Mahatma: Tan Yun-Shan and a forgotten ‘plea for Asia’
9 minutes ago Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Comments Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Comments In December 1928, a slight, bespectacled young man got his first glimpse of Gandhi. The Congress was holding its annual conference in Kolkata that year and thousands had flocked to it for a sighting of the famous leader – more than a lakh, according to the young man’s account. That first sighting is described in the language of devotion.
When it comes to Kashmir, Centre answers to no one – not even Parliament
Kashmir has been without high-speed internet for 14 months now and the Centre will not explain why. On Wednesday, the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Information Technology, headed by Congress leader Shashi Tharoor, asked home ministry officials why it had not been restored.
Tarun Gogoi (1936-2020): The chief minister who changed Assam slowly, slowly
21 minutes ago Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Comments Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Comments In 2016, Tarun Gogoi, then chief minister of Assam, was fighting his last assembly election. On a cool April night in Titabor, the Upper Assam constituency that he had represented for a decade and a half, he held court among party workers.
Why the new ‘Hindu Ecosystem’ that BJP leader Kapil Mishra is aiming to build sounds so menacing
If you have time on your hands and want to hone your special interests, why not join a club or a society? There are plenty of choices these days. If you are interested in community service, there is the Rotary Club or the Lions Club. Looking to mix fitness with pleasure? Try the Laughter Yoga Club. Want to expand your mind? There are plenty of book clubs cropping up in the cities. Or you could just join the Hindu Ecosystem. Becoming a member is very simple.
Despite strong words, a Biden-Harris administration is unlikely to change US position on Kashmir
Nov 16, 2020 · 09:00 am Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Share Tweet Email Reddit Print If United States President Donald Trump takes time off from golfing to concede the election, the country will soon have a Democrat government. Observers in the Indian establishment may have greeted this news with mixed feelings.
After Modi's surprise visit to Pakistan, the next step is obvious - sustained engagement
Springing a Christmas surprise, Prime Minister Narendra Modi “dropped in on” Lahore to wish Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on his birthday on Friday. This time there was no ginger handshake. As Modi descended from the plane in Lahore, he was greeted with a bear hug by Sharif. The last time an Indian prime minister had set foot in Pakistani soil was when former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee attended a South Asian summit in 2004.
Is the final NRC published in Assam unravelling under political pressure?
On October 21, the All Assam Students’ Union went on protest in Jorhat, burning an effigy of Bharatiya Janata Party president JP Nadda. Gathered outside the district commissioner’s office, they shouted slogans against the BJP chief, the BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Nadda’s offence: he had promised that the Citizenship (Amendment) Act would be implemented soon – it had only been stalled because of the pandemic.
Even as it promises ‘grassroots democracy’ in Kashmir, the Centre speaks an authoritarian language
Jammu and Kashmir will now have elected district development councils as part of its panchayati raj system. The Union Territory administration made the announcement on the weekend, just as regional political parties were regrouping after top leaders were released from detention. The changes to the panchayati raj act were intended to kickstart political activity, government officials claimed.
What the Maharashtra governor’s letter to Uddhav Thackeray says about the Indian republic
As Maharashtra Governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari this week gave his unsolicited advice on opening religious places closed amid the pandemic, he accused Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray of turning “secular”. He reminded Thackeray, a Shiv Sena leader, of his Hindutva credentials, which include visiting the “Ram temple” at Ayodhya. He exhorted the chief minister to reopen places of worship as soon as possible.
Gauhati High Court ordered detention centres to be moved out of jails – but that’s just geography
4 minutes ago Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Comments Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Comments In a judgment on October 7, the Gauhati High Court pointed out the obvious. People identified as foreigners and awaiting deportation or repatriation cannot be held in jails. Neither can people waiting to establish their citizenship. In March, the Centre said that there were 3,331 people identified as or suspected to be “foreigners” lodged in six detention centres across Assam.
Why did the BJP feel empowered to push through farm laws widely seen as anti-farmer?
14 minutes ago Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Share Tweet Email Reddit Print “Lootne ki chhoot.” Permission to loot. Farmers’ leader Amra Ram was pronouncing his verdict on the three farm Bills passed by Parliament in September.
What the name of the woman raped and battered in Hathras says about the crime
We know her name, the 19-year-old Dalit woman who was raped and brutalised by four Thakur men in Hathras. She died on September 29 and was cremated by the Uttar Pradesh police even as her family pleaded that they be allowed to take her body home. According to law, women who have been raped are to remain anonymous and any information identifying them is to be withheld from the public. That is unless the woman herself agrees to reveal her identity.
The costs of a cold war: India and China enter a punishing stalemate on the LAC this winter
7 minutes ago Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Soldiers at the Line of Actual Control in Ladakh are bracing for a hard winter. After the latest round of military and diplomatic talks, both sides have agreed not to pour fresh troops to the front. Going by reports, both sides agree on a roadmap to peace: disengage, de-escalate and eventually pull away troops from the area.
‘Fake news’ did not trigger India’s worst migrant crisis. Government apathy did
Going by the government’s response to questions in Parliament, there was no migrant crisis triggered by a nationwide lockdown declared at four hours’ notice by the prime minister on March 23. In reply to a question on why the lockdown to contain the coronavirus had been declared at such short notice, Minister of State for Home Nityanand Rai replied it was to “stop the untraceable movement of people from one place to another within the country”.
Beyond Modi-Xi summits: To avoid military escalation, what are India’s options?
9 minutes ago Ipsita Chakravarty Share Tweet Email Reddit Print Share Tweet Email Reddit Print In October 2019, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping sipped on tender coconut water and took in the sights of Mamallapuram, a seaside town in Tamil Nadu. At one point, Modi is said to have offered Xi a paper napkin, “like a close family member or friend”. But all was not well.
Why Assam’s NRC failed to address the social and economic anxieties it was to resolve for good
A year after the National Register of Citizens was published in Assam, no community in the state seems satisfied with the results. The stated aim of Assam’s NRC, a list of citizens living in the state, was to sort Indians from undocumented migrants. To make it to the list, applicants had to prove they or their ancestors had lived in the country before midnight on March 24, 1971, the eve of the Bangladesh War.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Ipsita
Contact Ipsita, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack