Embattled Washington Township school Superintendent Eric Hibbs has lost another battle with the South Jersey school system to get $27,000 in merit pay. A motion to award Hibbs the bonus pay for performance failed by a 4-4 vote with one abstention at a contentious meeting Tuesday night. Five favorable votes are needed for adoption. This was the third time since August that the nine-member board has not approved the merit pay, likely setting up another legal showdown between Hibbs and the board.