There is an easy conceptual pairing between India and the United States, the world’s largest democracy and the world’s oldest. India’s role in the development of the US software sector—jumpstarted by the Y2K problem and the agility of a few Indian information technology firms—has been the most prominent example of US-India ties. These headline examples often translate into the idea of a special US-India relationship.
Is this you? As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.
Claim your profile
Articles by Nirvikar Singh
Economy check: India aims to achieve net zero emissions by 2070. Is this feasible?
India’s per capita energy consumption is less than 40% of the world’s average, but its energy system relies heavily on coal for power generation, as well as for industrial production. Oil is most important for transport, and biomass is most important for residential heating and cooking. Excluding biomass, in 2019, India’s total primary energy supply (TPES) was 734 million tons of oil equivalent (Mtoe), with just over half of this being covered by domestic production.
How real is India’s growth?
In the latest case, there were discussions that were of a similar technical nature to those in the past, involving collection and estimation methods for the raw data, methods for adjusting for inflation, and so on.
Tap household savings for growth
If India is to grow at the rate the government wants, it will need to invest more and invest wisely. A long list of financial sector reforms to make this possible are desirable and feasible, as I argued in my last column. The current process of identifying and implementing financial sector reforms has been going on for almost two decades, although earlier efforts began soon after the original trade and industry reforms of 1991.
Can Punjab save itself? Short answer is No
THE current crisis in Punjab is a continuation of problems that arose over five decades ago. Its underlying causes are deeper than certain acts of Sikh religious leaders or the state's politicians. The problems are deeper and structural. They are embedded in socioeconomic factors that matter, but the main cause is a dysfunctional national food security policy. Can Punjab save itself? The short answer is: No. Can Punjab be saved? The answer is: Yes.
The cost of capital: Financing Viksit Bharat
Economic growth is driven by investments that yield positive returns, including innovations that make those investments more productive. Putting capital to work is at the heart of capitalism. To grow at the rate required by the government’s goal of making India an advanced economy by 2047, the country needs to do better in putting capital to work, through some combination of increased investment and more effectively deployed investment.
How India can navigate a turbulent world
The US-Israel war on Iran has been, in some ways, the last nail in the coffin of the post-World War II global order. It has exposed the limits of US power, changed expectations regarding global energy markets, and emphasised to all countries that the old rules pertaining to international economic and security matters are no longer to be relied upon.
Three things India can do to grow
The current US administration has been remarkable in its rejection of the post-World War II global order, from last year’s tariff wars (still continuing) to the more real war on Iran. This latter war is having much more serious consequences than the tariff turmoil, disrupting energy supplies, destroying infrastructure, and consuming substantial quantities of real resources (as any war does).
Job deficit: Gaps in economic policymaking
A persistent characteristic of India’s economic growth has been the lack of adequate job growth to accompany it. Since growth in per capita income partly comes from growth in productivity, some of this is unavoidable. Even China, the most spectacular case of economic growth in history, has struggled with generating adequate levels of employment, but India’s problem is more severe. Those who are most likely to be openly unemployed rather than working in low-wage jobs are those with college degrees.
Union Budget and beyond
By Nirvikar Singh, This year’s Union Budget was almost simultaneous with several events that have significance for its economic future. A formal trade deal with the European Union came just before the Budget, and an announcement of a trade deal with the US soon after.
How to fix Delhi’s air pollution disaster
By Nirvikar Singh Why has Delhi’s air pollution problem persisted? Is there a way to fix it? For at least a decade, Delhi’s air has been hazardous for several months each winter. The problem is visible, palpable, and pervasive. It has led to multiple government reports, many research papers, and global news stories. But this winter, the conditions faced by Delhi’s residents were no better than in previous years.
India’s Goldilocks economy
By Nirvikar Singh The latest growth figure for India, clocking in at 8.2% despite an uncertain global economic situation, bodes well for the country’s medium-term economic outlook. Combined with unusually low inflation, the numbers suggest something close to a Goldilocks economy—not too hot, not too cold, but (close to) “just right”.
Nobel nod to innovation drivers
This year’s prize in economics in honour of Alfred Nobel went to economic historian Joel Mokyr and economic theorists Philippe Aghion and Peter Howitt. Their work shares the theme of trying to understand the role of innovation in growth. Economic historians look at the past. Economic theorists build abstract models. Does any of this work have lessons for India as it seeks to become an advanced economy in just over two decades?
India in the cross hairs
By Nirvikar Singh US policy under the current administration has been marked by several characteristics. One is the personalisation and centralisation of policymaking, including a disregard for legal structures and societal norms, in favour of the exercise of power to the maximum extent possible. Another feature is an attempt to roll back those norms by many decades—reasserting social inequalities that had been slowly redressed over a long period of time.
Don’t rise to any bait from Trump
By Nirvikar Singh The Trump tariff saga continues to follow a winding path with unexpected twists and turns. Dealing with the situation is a bit like playing a video game, where hazards and monsters keep appearing and difficult decisions must be made at many stages without a clear sense of what lies ahead. In this case, the “final boss” does not just come at the end, but appears repeatedly.
From rules-based negotiation to alpha male tactics: In US-China trade war, norms take a back seat
The US-China tangle over trade has sometimes seemed like an alpha-male exercise in dominance displays, especially on the US side – the human political equivalent of gorilla dominance displays such as chest-beating, charges and vocalisations. Gorillas rarely fight, and they never sit down to negotiate. In that sense, the US-China trade “war” has quietened down to what could be a relatively normal set of trade negotiations. Trade negotiations are inherently complex.
An opportunity to chew on
By Nirvikar Singh One piece of fallout from Donald Trump’s tariff chaos seems to be Apple’s announcement that it will shift more iPhone production for the US market from China to India. The Covid pandemic had already been a driver for firms to seek diversification of manufacturing sites. Apple began iPhone production in India in 2017, wooed by Indian policies to promote “making in India”. Over the years, Apple has shifted from making only older iPhone models in India to the latest versions.
Impact of Trump’s tariffs on India will be lower than for other countries, including China
Donald Trump clearly believes in “Make America Great Again”. But what does “greatness” mean to him, for the other (less-noble) goals for which the slogan is a cover, and a remarkably chaotic implementation of his programme? In this bigger picture, the new tariff policies announced on April 2 seem relatively benign. After all, the United States has been a global leader in the openness of its economy, and has regularly struggled to get other economies to reciprocate fully.
A major reset of higher education
By Nirvikar Singh The United States, along with being an innovator in democratic government, experimented with higher education in ways that shaped the modern university. The founders of the country were creatures of the European enlightenment, and believers in education as freedom of thought as well as practical experimentation. The US borrowed from various European models, including Germany, which led the world in the 19th century in research, and the creation of new scientific knowledge.
Beyond staying the course
By Nirvikar Singh India’s recent Union Budget had the flavour of “staying the course”, which is not surprising, given the continuity of the government at the Centre. There were proposals for adjusting personal income taxes, incentivising private sector research and development (R&D), providing more credit to micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs), development of nuclear energy, and the usual number of more-or-less targeted welfare schemes.
AI and jobs in India
By Nirvikar Singh India’s economic growth has been notoriously stingy in generating jobs that pay better than traditional jobs like agriculture or low-level services. Among the reasons for this undesirable feature of India’s growth are policies that either discourage using labour versus capital, or discourage the creation of productive, dynamic firms, irrespective of how they manage their labour-capital mix.
India and the US elections
By Nirvikar Singh The importance of the recent US elections for India cannot be overstated. The political landscape in the US has shifted dramatically. Donald Trump is not just an America-first ideologue, though that has been a part of his thinking for decades. He is also driven completely by self-interest, and is totally transactional in his approach. He is also not someone who respects experts, especially those with scientific expertise.
Growth, jobs and manufacturing
By Nirvikar Singh The latest numbers suggest that India’s economic growth is slowing down, though not by much. Some of this can be chalked up to a return to trend, after the Covid downturn and recovery. There are also clouds gathering with the continuation and escalation of conflict in West Asia and Ukraine, and these are affecting the entire global economy. Indian policymakers can only focus on what they control, however.
Deficits, debt and India’s growth prospects
By Nirvikar Singh India’s government debt is about the highest it has ever been, at 82% of GDP. This is down from its post-pandemic high, but still higher than historical averages. The stock of debt is a major determinant of interest payments to be made, which can crowd out productive government spending, and slow down growth. Interest payments also depend on rates, which are influenced by perceptions of risk. So high debt levels can raise interest rates and create a negative feedback loop.
The politics of pensions and savings
By Nirvikar Singh India is set to grow consistently at about 7%, which is enough to double GDP every decade. That is exceptional compared to historical averages, but short of East Asian miracle growth rates. To achieve those growth rates, and meet aspirations of reaching advanced country income levels, India has to grow faster. That, in turn, requires some combination of higher rates of investment and greater growth impacts of investment expenditures.
The Budget and the end of ‘reform’
By Nirvikar Singh The Union Budget is no longer about ‘reform’. Instead it involves incremental adjustments to policy within a new economic growth strategy, one focused on business growth When India’s national government occupied the “commanding heights” of the economy — at least in theory — Union Budgets were official expressions of that position.
Punjab’s Green Revolution-era success is long over. Four factors now constrain its economy
Also read: Rural Punjab is a time capsule. Its new story is the old one: declining economy, rising religiosity, bad politics The share of agriculture and allied activities in GSVA (gross state value added) in Punjab based on advance estimates was 26.7% while the sector accounted for 24.6% of employment in 2022-23. Punjab’s share of agriculture had not declined much since the early 2000s and was higher than other Indian states with similar levels of per capita income.
Restating status as largest democracy
India’s recently-concluded national general election was big in every possible sense. The process lasted longer than ever before, and more people voted than ever before. The choices made by voters across the country reaffirmed India’s status as the world’s largest democracy, since major issues of representation and material well-being were at stake.
Pivoting India's growth strategy - Opinion News
India’s general election is just kicking off, but it is unlikely to change the country’s political equilibrium. One of the factors favouring a continuation of this equilibrium is the development of a robust, albeit restricted, sense of national pride. There is evidence that many Indians view the country as a rising global power, and the country’s leadership that is not averse to making that claim.
Happiness in India: India’s economic growth over time does not show up in improved happiness score and ranking
The first World Happiness Report (WHR) was published in 2012 by The Earth Institute, led at the time by economist Jeffrey Sachs. Since then, the WHR has expanded in scope and detail, and is now published by the Wellbeing Research Centre at Oxford University. Many economists have been involved, but they have also relied on experts from other disciplines such as psychology — an essential contributor.
The economic future
India is currently the world’s fastest-growing economy, and many analysts and commentators are optimistic about its growth prospects over the next few years. Reasons for optimism include stronger technological foundations, diversifying exports, improved infrastructure, and increased foreign portfolio and direct investment. The latter trend has been fuelled partly by global investors moving away from China, with India’s stock market rising while China’s fell.
Understanding the shackles of opportunity: Dependent visas and the people tied to them
BOOK REVIEW Understanding the shackles of opportunity: Dependent visas and the people tied to them The Opportunity Trap: High-Skilled Workers, Indian Families and the Failures of the Dependent Visa Programby Pallavi Banerjee First published: 19 February 2024 No abstract is available for this article. REFERENCES 1Chakravorty, Sanjoy, Devesh Kapur, and Nirvikar Singh. 2016. The Other One Percent: Indians in America. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2Parreñas, Rhacel Salazar. 2005.
Moonshots and mind games: India can achieve world-class excellence with its domestic institutions and resources
In August, India became only the fourth country to successfully soft-land a spacecraft on the moon. Given the complexity of such missions, this was a mark of leading-edge expertise in science and technology that stands out more than building nuclear bombs, or innovation in software or biotech. This success was rightly lauded as a major signal of what India can accomplish under the right circumstances.
An economic strategy for India: Many bottlenecks and challenges that India faces require deeper integration across levels of govt
Last year saw the 75th anniversary of India’s Independence, a milestone that led to considerable reflection, as well as visions of where India’s economy could be at the country’s centenary. In fact, every Independence Day marks a milestone, and this one led me to reflect back to an event from half a year ago—the “India Dialog” conference held at Stanford University. Among numerous presentations, what stood out were those that offered a roadmap of India’s economic strategy.
India’s new research push
The announcement of plans for a new National Research Foundation (NRF), meant to replace the Science and Engineering Research Board (SERB) that was created in 2008, has generated excitement and debate. The NRF proposal has its origins in a 2019 report requested by the Prime Minister regarding India’s lagging performance in research spending, quality of research papers, patents, and university-based research.
India’s green transition
As the world gets dangerously warmer, and almost every country is setting targets for achieving “net zero” emission goals, developing nations face the additional challenge of lifting the material conditions of their populations. In other words, economic development has to be consistent with sustaining the planet.
India’s teaching troubles
India faces an enormous skilling challenge. Only half of college graduates are employable. The problem is even deeper, since the lower rungs of the education ladder are often broken. In my last column, I suggested allowing large-scale entry by foreign universities, including importation of their regulatory frameworks, curricula and faculty. That will help a great deal, but domestic reforms are also needed.
India’s skilling challenge
When US treasury secretary Janet Yellen visited India late last year, on a mission to deepen economic and strategic ties between the two countries, her Indian counterpart, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman, highlighted “skilling at scale” as one of India’s major challenges. Studies by the National Skill Development Corporation and the National Policy on Skill Development and Entrepreneurship merely confirm what is well known—India has a serious skill deficit.
Decarbonising India
If we give India its own personality, we can assert that India has to grow, and India wants to grow. Economic growth can get people out of poverty, create livelihoods, and improve their lives in many ways. When people in countries around the world are asked about their levels of life satisfaction, the most important factor that predicts their average satisfaction—the World Happiness Index—is GDP per capita.
National champions vs championing policy
The Economic Survey of India painted an optimistic picture of the nation’s economic prospects, emphasising a relatively broad-based recovery from the pandemic shock, increased investment, stabilising private and public sector finances, and improvements in physical and digital infrastructure. At times it is difficult to disentangle plans from accomplishments, but the tone is one of quiet confidence.
Arriving, ascending, emerging
As India embarked on its policy reform path three-plus decades ago, the country’s economic growth rate was dwarfed by the growth rate of the number of books about these changes and their consequences. Arriving, ascending, and emerging were all adjectives used in different book titles, as was the idea that it was finally India’s turn to bring prosperity to its people. Not every analysis was upbeat, and one title referred to India’s long road to that prosperity.
Friends from a different shore
In 1989, American academic Ronald Takaki wrote a pioneering history of Asian Americans, Strangers from a Different Shore. His starting point was that immigration to America (excluding the forced movements of slavery) had typically been viewed as coming from Europe, with those from Asia—the different shore—being invisible in these narratives. He wrote to counter this invisibility.
India and globalisation
The world has changed dramatically in the past two years. The two most significant triggers of this change have been the Covid pandemic and the Russian invasion of Ukraine. These two events have disrupted the structures of economic globalisation. National policy responses have been less than ideal, with the largest mistake being the US Federal Reserve’s tardiness in combating rising inflation. Their delayed action is shocking the global system even further.
The ‘good jobs’ challenge India faces
After 75 years of existence as an independent nation, India’s biggest challenge remains the need to create more “good jobs” for its people. The shift from the original development strategy of government occupying the “commanding heights” of the economy, along with goals of self-reliance and import substitution, to one of “economic reform,” which broadly means greater reliance on the private sector and markets, has led to higher growth rates of GDP, the standard measure of the economy’s output.
Law in the time of war
A conflict is raging in Eurasia since late February this year. After decades of conflicts being associated with Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria and parts of Africa, a war is being fought by White men on both sides – Russians and Ukrainians, much to the horror to most of the world, particularly to the Europeans who thought wars were something distant.
India @ 75: Temper celebrations for now
As India marks its 75th anniversary as an independent nation in the post-colonial era, there is much to celebrate. India has made considerable material progress, retained democratic governance structures, preserved some degree of individual freedoms and human rights, and maintained its territorial unity and sovereignty.
Accelerating science entrepreneurship
Three decades ago, economic historian Joel Mokyr wrote a book titled The Lever of Riches with the subtitle “Technological Creativity and Economic Progress,” describing the nature of the lever—in the physical world, a tool for multiplying force. In Mokyr’s story, innovation is the lever, and economic progress is the accomplishment. If we are in what some have described as the fourth industrial revolution or technological progress, then what should India be doing to ride this wave?
Privatising India’s banks
In 1969, India’s government nationalised the country’s banking industry. The goal was to make financial services more inclusive, and to spur economic development by directing the financial sector. This was in keeping with the post-independence strategy of occupying the “commanding heights” of the economy, but that approach was already showing signs of dysfunction by that time.
Edtech’s future in India: Affordability and access can be casualties of innovation unless they receive explicit attention
Edtech, or the use of digital technology tools for education, particularly including online learning, promises to be an important contributor to India’s economic development. India’s education system has suffered from inadequate resources, outdated curricula, rigidity, and poor incentives. The New Educational Policy of 2020 and its immediate predecessors marked some fresh thinking in the direction of improving learning processes and increasing flexibility.
India’s Net Zero strategy: India can be a role model for developing countries
The recent Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change made it clear that the world faces catastrophic consequences of rising temperatures unless nations make significant new efforts to alter this course, by reducing greenhouse gas emissions. ‘Net Zero’ refers to offsetting new greenhouse gas emissions with other actions, to (supposedly) make net emissions zero.
Show More
loading
Actions
Is this you?
As a journalist, you can create a free Muck Rack account to customize your profile, list your contact preferences, and upload a portfolio of your best work.Get in touch with Nirvikar
Contact Nirvikar, search articles and posts on X, monitor coverage, and track replies from one place.
Learn more about Muck Rack