Ask 10 baseball fans who the greatest player of all time is, and you’ll probably get 10 different answers. Each generation has its own GOAT with fans in his corner, and stacking up the greats from different eras is a tall task. How do you compare Babe Ruth to Barry Bonds? Or Cy Young to Greg Maddux? And where do you even start with factoring in a modern unicorn like Shohei Ohtani? Ranking the best of the best isn’t just about racking up stats and calling it a day.